September 14, 2021
In the last three (3) years, there has been a significant increase in the number of Transfer Pricing (TP) audits conducted by the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS). TP audits are generally lengthy, involving the submission of significant amounts of documents and attendance of various reconciliation meetings. From experience, despite international best practices and taxpayers’ efforts to defend their Transfer Pricing positions, taxpayers often have to compromise and agree with positions adopted by the FIRS with respect to certain complex transactions such as intangible transactions.
This is usually due to the unwillingness of taxpayers to proceed to litigation because of the lengthy and expensive judicial process in Nigeria as well as the absence of precedence in the courts to guide the treatment of such transactions. Globally, intangible transactions are a source of significant.
TP controversy due to their complexity. Tax authorities are usually skeptical about these transactions, and require substantial proof from taxpayers to justify royalty costs or the appropriateness of royalty income derived.
In this article, we discuss intangible transactions and share our experiences from TP audits (focusing on the manufacturing industry), highlighting the FIRS’ treatment of these transactions.
What are Intangibles?
Paragraph 6.6 of the OECD TP Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations (OECD Guidelines) defines intangibles as; “something which is not a physical asset or a financial asset, which is capable of being owned or controlled for use in commercial activities, and whose use or transfer would be compensated had it occurred in a transaction between independent parties in comparable circumstance.”
According to the OECD Guidelines, intangibles may be broadly categorized into marketing and trade intangibles. Marketing intangibles relate to marketing activities that aid in the commercial exploitation of a product/service and/or has an important promotional value for the product concerned. Examples include trademarks, trade names, customer lists, customer relationships etc. Trade intangibles are intangibles that are not marketing intangibles. Examples include, patents, know-how and trade secrets, propriety formulas, rights under contracts and government licenses etc.
Prior to the revision of the OECD Guidelines in 2017, ownership of intangibles tended to hinge on legal ownership. This meant that an entity within a Multinational Enterprise (MNE) group was deemed to own an intangible, if it possessed legal title, which entitled it to earn remuneration from the licensee for the exploitation of the intangibles.
The revised OECD Guidelines clearly indicates that legal ownership is not sufficient to confer on the owner, a right to earn the returns from the use of the intangible asset. Other members of the MNE group depending on the functions performed, assets utilized and risks assumed toward the Development, Enhancement, Maintenance, Protection or Exploitation (DEMPE functions) of the intangible may be entitled to some of the returns. Entities within the MNE Group who carry out at least one of these functions are referred to as economic owners of the intangible, and should be compensated for their value adding activities.
The remuneration for the transfer of intangibles depends on the nature of the transfer of rights, considering, the functions performed by parties to the arrangement and the profit and loss variable the intangible drives. For example, where a marketing intangible drives revenue of the licensee because of significant brand recognition, the remuneration is typically a royalty rate as a percentage of the licensee’s net sales/ revenue that the intangible is driving.
Treatment of Intangibles during an Audit
Intangible transactions face more scrutiny from the FIRS due to their complexity and the fact that the associated royalty payments are usually outflows. During the audit, the FIRS often requires documentary evidence to demonstrate the following: