August 23, 2022
The Federal High Court (“FHC” or “the Court”) sitting in Abuja, on 27 June 2022, delivered a judgement on the applicability of tax amendments to transactions that arose prior to such amendments. The decision arose from an appeal by Accugas Limited (Accugas or the Company) against the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) and the Attorney General of the Federation.
The lone issue for determination in the case was whether (in light of the provisions of sections 6(1)(b) and (c) of the Interpretation Act) the provisions of the Finance Act, 2019 (FA 2019) can retroactively apply to periods, transactions, activities, and income earned prior to 13 January 2020 when the Finance Act was assented to. In this article, we have analyzed the decision of the FHC and the potential implications on businesses.
Background
In determining income tax payable in a particular tax year, companies are assessed to tax on a preceding year basis, in line with Section 29 (1) of Companies Income Tax Act (CITA). Thus, the tax assessment for a current year, 20X2 is based on the financial statements of the previous year, 20X1. In filing income tax returns, companies are required by Section 55 of CITA to submit amongst others, current year tax computations and audited financial statements which form the basis of preparing the tax computations. The tax returns are due for filing not later than six (6) months from the end of a company’s accounting year-end.
Where, in any year of assessment, a company has no profits to be taxed, has no tax payable or the tax payable is less than minimum tax, such a company is required to pay minimum tax, except it meets any of the conditions for exemption, as stated in Section 33(3) of CITA.
One of such conditions for exemption from minimum tax, prior to FA 2019, was having “at least 25% imported equity capital”. FA 2019, which was signed into law by the President on 13 January 2020, amended a number of tax provisions, including Section 33(3)b of CITA. The amendment to Section 33(3)b of CITA replaced “a company with at least 25 per cent imported equity capital” with “a company that earns gross turnover of less than ₦25,000,000 in the relevant year of assessment”. This amendment repealed the minimum tax exemption previously granted to companies with at least 25% imported equity, prior to FA 2019.
The key question therefore, is whether companies with at least 25% imported equity, prior to the enactment of the FA 2019, can still enjoy minimum tax exemption for periods/transactions that preceded the amendments to Section 33(3)b of CITA by FA 2019. This was the issue brought for determination at the FHC, sitting in Abuja, by Accugas against the FIRS.
Overview of the Federal High Court’s Decision
Accugas, with a financial year end of 31 December, had more than 25% imported equity as at 31 December 2019. Based on its audited financial statements for 2019 financial year, Accugas made a loss and had no taxable profits for that year, Thus, the Company was ordinarily liable to minimum tax assessment, in line with Section 33 of CITA. Given the requirement to file its income tax returns by 30 June 2020 and the amendments introduced by FA 2019, Accugas had, in July 2020, written to FIRS to confirm if the amendment to Section 33(3)b of CITA would affect its right to enjoy minimum tax exemption on its income earned between January 2019 and December 2019.
In its response, FIRS stated that the amendments made to CITA by FA 2019 apply to the Company’s tax returns for 2020 year of assessment (YOA), based on its income earned between January 2019 and December 2019. FIRS’ position was on the basis that the 2020 YOA tax returns became due for filing in June 2020, after the passage of FA 2019 in January 2020. Thus, Accugas could not enjoy exemption from minimum tax on its income earned between January and December 2019.