February 18, 2025
The long-awaited Guidelines on Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) [the Guidelines] was finally issued by the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) on 27 November, 2024. Nigeria was one of the first African countries to include APA provisions in its Transfer Pricing (TP) Regulations as far back as 2012, but it took the FIRS over a decade to make the provision effective with the issuance of the Guidelines.
With increased pressure on the FIRS to mobilize revenue to meet the significantly high 2025 budget, the obvious question for Nigerian taxpayers affected by TP is “how does the Guidelines affect us?”
This article provides insights into the aspects of the Guidelines that taxpayers can take advantage of (the Good), the challenging aspects that taxpayers need to be aware of and mitigate (the Bad), and the highly risky aspects of the Guidelines that should be addressed by the FIRS (the Ugly).
Key Highlights of the Guidelines
The Guidelines defines an Advance Pricing Agreements as an arrangement between taxpayer(s) and a tax administration that determines in advance of a controlled transaction, an appropriate set of criteria for the determination of the transfer price of controlled transactions in accordance with the Arm’s Length Principle (ALP) over a specified period of time on the fulfillment of certain terms and conditions.
There are three types of APAs: a unilateral Advance Pricing Agreements, which will be between a taxpayer and the FIRS; a bilateral APA, which will be between the local taxpayer, a foreign related party, the FIRS, and the Competent Authority (CA) of the foreign related party; and a multilateral APA, which will be between the taxpayer, its related parties in two or more countries, the FIRS, and the CAs of the foreign related parties. Bilateral and multilateral APAs can only be entered into with Nigeria’s tax treaty partners.
The minimum annual controlled transactions threshold for an Advance Pricing Agreements is $10 million for a single transaction and $50 million for a group of transactions.
An APA will apply for a maximum period of 3 years from the date indicated in the APA. However, it may be renewed for a maximum term of 3 years and rolled back to prior years for a maximum of 3 years before the APA commencement.
The Good
APAs provide a number of benefits to taxpayers, including the following:
First, an Advance Pricing Agreements provides certainty to taxpayers involved in high-risk, high-value controlled transactions such as intangibles, procurement arrangements, and Cost Contribution Arrangements (CCAs). High risk transactions are likely to be contentious during a TP audit with the FIRS, as such, an APA becomes a proactive alternative dispute resolution mechanism that enables the taxpayer seek resolution on the appropriate arm’s length pricing or outcome. As a result, the taxpayer achieves certainty over the APA period, as long as the taxpayer continues to implement the agreed terms and conditions of the APA over the APA period.
Second, for cross border controlled transactions, bilateral or multilateral APAs might help mitigate double taxation risks. Where Nigeria has a double tax treaty with the country of the foreign related party(ies), a bilateral or multilateral Advance Pricing Agreements enables the CAs of the jurisdictions involved agree on an acceptable arm’s length transfer price and where necessary corresponding adjustments can be made to financials to ensure that the taxpayer and its related parties do not suffer double tax.
Third, APAs can be cost saving to the taxpayer in the long run. Even though in the short run, APAs can be costly in terms of time and financial resources, considering the taxpayer’s ability to roll the outcome back for 3 years and renew it for another 3 years, the taxpayer may enjoy cost savings because of minimal TP compliance work, and no FIRS TP audits for transactions covered by the APA.
Finally, the Advance Pricing Agreements process being voluntary is generally expected to be less adversarial than TP audits, so it should improve relationships with tax authorities. A Taxpayer voluntarily chooses to proactively engage the FIRS to review its financials and other relevant documents to determine an appropriate TP method and arm’s length outcome. As such, the transparent and open discussion is often more cooperative and helps develop a more cordial relationship with tax authorities.