April 29, 2025
As Transfer Pricing (TP) enforcement continues to intensify in Nigeria, companies are increasingly finding themselves under scrutiny, not just for how they price their Related Party Transactions (RPTs), but also how well they describe and characterise such RPTs. One key area that often makes or breaks a taxpayer’s case during audits is the functional analysis. While taxpayers may think the focus should be on pricing and benchmarking of RPTs, the foundation of a credible and defensible transaction starts with a well-articulated functional analysis.
In this article, we will explore what a functional analysis is, its importance, especially in dispute resolution in the TP audit process and steps to having a robust functional analysis.
What is Functional Analysis and Why is it Important?
A functional analysis is an evaluation of an RPT to identify the economically relevant activities undertaken (functions performed), assets employed, and risks assumed by the parties to the transaction. These information is usually contained in the Functions, Assets and Risks (FAR or functional) analysis section in the TP documentation, and it is a critical part of the report.
The functional analysis serves as the bedrock for understanding the RPTs and properly characterising the parties and transaction. It analyses the various components of the RPT, providing detailed explanations of what occurred during the period and the role of each party to the RPT. This information is crucial for the taxpayer and the tax authority.
The functional analysis should help create a clear picture of value creation within the value chain of the RPT. It identifies the related party that undertakes strategic activities (such as research and development, procurement, or marketing, strategic decision making), who performs routine functions, who owns key intangibles or physical assets and who bears the risks. The functional characterisation of an entity also informs the expected returns that should be earned and how profits should be allocated between related parties.
In addition to providing information about the RPT, a functional analysis is essential as it can inform the type of comparables to select for a comparability analysis, and the TP method to be adopted in testing the RPT. A robust functional analysis ensures that only companies with similar business operations are included in benchmarking studies. Without a proper breakdown of the functions performed, benchmarkings may be fundamentally flawed.
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) in Chapter 3 of the OECD Guidelines, provides a 9-step approach to comparability, with step 3 being “Understanding the controlled transaction(s) under examination, based in particular on a functional analysis, in order to choose the tested party (where needed), the most appropriate transfer pricing method to the circumstances of the case, the financial indicator that will be tested (in the case of a transactional profit method), and to identify the significant comparability factors that should be taken into account.”
The importance of the functional analysis is emphasised in 5 (2b) of the Nigeria TP Regulations (NTPR) which states that “the most appropriate transfer pricing method shall be used taking into account …the nature of the controlled transactions determined, in particular, through an analysis of the functions performed, assets employed and risks assumed”. On performing comparability analyses. Regulation 11 (4b) also states that “in determining whether two or more transactions are comparable, the following factors shall be considered to the extent that they are economically relevant to the facts and circumstances of the transactions… (b) The functions undertaken by the persons entering into the transaction taking into account the assets used and risk assumed.””
Ultimately, the functional analysis goes beyond mere documentation of an RPT as it tells the story behind the intercompany transaction and supports the logic behind the chosen TP method, comparables and ultimately the pricing.
Functional Analysis and TP Audits
Many TP disputes arise not because the pricing is obviously inappropriate, but because the functional analysis fails to align with the economic reality. A poor or inconsistent functional analysis undermines the credibility of the entire TP position of a company. It may result in the FIRS challenging the substance of the transaction, selection of the tested party, the application of the TP method or even recharacterising or disallowing the transaction entirely.
In a TP audit, there is an emphasis on substance over form. With a poorly constructed or outdated functional analysis, the Federal Inland revenue Service (FIRS) may query the substance of an RPT, arguing that there is no economic benefit to the RPT or there is no evidence that the RPT occurred/ the parties involved could perform the functions listed. In this case, instead of determining an appropriate remuneration for the RPT, the FIRS would totally disallow such transaction. A well-documented functional analysis can support the substance of an RPT, where it contains the relevant information to prove economic substance and the ability of the related parties to engage in the RPT. It is also pertinent that the functional analysis aligns with the form (agreements, invoices) of the transaction.