August 10, 2021
The doctrine of legitimate expectation is a common law principle, which requires that public authorities respect a consistent practice or representation made by them to members of the public. The doctrine generally operates to limit a public authority’s ability to act contrary to a person’s legitimate expectation where such expectation is based on a consistent practice or representation made by the public authority to them. The doctrine is rooted in the equitable principle of fairness and is aimed at ensuring a degree of legal certainty.
The relevance of this doctrine came to the fore again, when on 10th June 2021, the Tax Appeal Tribunal (TAT) in the case of Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) v New Cross Petroleum Limited (New Cross) held that New Cross was liable to pay the taxes assessed by the FIRS for 2011 to 2012, even though the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission (NIPC) had previously granted Pioneer Status Incentive (PSI) to New Cross for 2008 – 2012 (5 years). The NIPC had subsequently reduced the PSI earlier granted to New Cross from 5 years to 3 years and communicated this via a letter dated 26th January 2015, thereby withdrawing the PSI for years 2011 and 2012. This article seeks to analyse the applicability of the doctrine of legitimate expectation in the resolution of tax disputes, with the New Cross case as a case study and the extent (if any) to which a taxpayer can rely on representations made by the tax authorities or other public officials in organising their tax affairs.
Brief Facts of the New Cross Case
New Cross filed its tax returns for the 2011 and 2012 Years of Assessment and attached its PSI certificate issued by NIPC. However, the FIRS issued a notice of assessment dated 29th January, 2015 and demand notice dated 30th January 2015 on the Company. Attempts by the parties to resolve the issues were unsuccessful. Thus, in August 2020, the FIRS instituted an action at the TAT, arguing amongst other things, that the NIPC lacked the power to issue PSI certificate to New Cross and that the PSI certificate issued to New Cross for a duration of 5 years is invalid in law given that the Industrial Development (Income Tax Relief) Act (IDITRA) allows only for an initial period of 3 years renewable for two additional years. The TAT agreed with the argument of the FIRS and held that the PSI certificate issued to New Cross had elapsed based on the reduction by the NIPC and that the IDITRA, does not cover the oil and gas industry.
Key Issues Arising from the New Cross Case
PSI was introduced in 1971 and the objective of the incentive is to grant tax exemption and tax reliefs to qualifying industries and products designated as priority areas, as a means of driving investment and growth in those industries. Based on the strict interpretation of the IDITRA, which defines ‘Principal Act’ as the Companies Income Tax Act (CITA), it can be inferred that PSI should ordinarily apply only to companies taxable under CITA. Furthermore, Section 26 of the IDITRA provides that the IDITRA should be read as one with the CITA.