August 17, 2021
It is difficult to completely prevent fraud in an organisation. Institutions with strong internal control measures can be exposed to risk of fraud or misconduct by employees, third parties, vendors, business partners, customers or a combination of these. In recent months, there have been public reports of allegations of unethical conduct in organisations ranging from the New York State Governor’s office to the Nigerian Police Force (NPF). A problem in many organisations is that oftentimes, suspicions of misconduct are rarely formally reported for the appropriate investigations to take place. Unfortunately, stakeholders harbour concerns without making any formal complaints.
Organisations with strong measures to detect fraud or misconduct benefit from having a variety of channels from which to observe and respond to suspicions of fraud or misconduct. Top companies conduct thorough internal audits, have the senior leadership of the company regularly reiterate the company’s zero-tolerance stance, hold frequent workshops and focus groups to get employees comfortable with reporting concerns, and have effective internal or external whistleblowing hotlines.
Since the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) released the Nigerian Code of Corporate Governance (NCCG) in 2018, there has been an increase in the number of companies that have established a hotline for witnesses to report concerns.
However, beyond having fraud detection mechanisms in place, the company’s response to allegations is also important. When allegations are made, the best practice is to conduct thorough and effective investigations to ascertain the veracity or otherwise. Investigations into allegations may be conducted internally, outsourced or through a combination of both methods.
Internal or in-house investigations are usually conducted by an investigation team typically, but not necessarily, in the internal audit department. The team handles the allegations from the receipt of the complaint to the completion of the fact-finding mission. The team may also engage with employees in other departments of the company to gather evidence, as necessary.
For this, companies need to have personnel who are skilled and experienced in conducting investigations. The staff in the investigation team should have technical competence, which may be evidenced by a relevant certificate such as the Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) or Professional Certified Investigator (PCI) and suitable continuous education. Investigation personnel should have sufficient knowledge of common fraud schemes, investigation techniques, specialized investigations such as cyber investigations, and relevant laws and regulations.
In-house investigations are usually the preferred choice for fraud or misconduct involving minor infringements or relatively small amounts of money. The appeal of this type of investigation is that it could be cheaper for the company, especially on a one-off basis. The company can use employees that are already on its payroll and rather than recruit an independent investigator.
Another benefit of in-house investigations is that the investigator, being a member of the company, is likely to be able to use cues from their experiences in the company and from previous investigations to ask more probing questions and complete the investigation quicker.