September 8, 2026
Cost recovery has always been one of the most contested line items in a Production Sharing Contract (PSC) as it is impacted by technical judgment, contract interpretation, and tax law; three things that can pull in different directions regarding the validity of an expense. Two developments over the past year have increased that friction rather than resolved it, namely the consolidation of Nigeria’s tax framework under the Nigeria Tax Act (NTA), and Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission’s (NUPRC or the Commission) move to attach cost benchmarks directly to tax outcomes. This article sets out where the pressure points now sit and what operators should be watching.
The Legislative Backdrop
The NTA, which took effect as part of the broader 2025 tax reform package, repeals the Deep Offshore and Inland Basin Production Sharing Contracts Act alongside the Companies Income Tax Act, Personal Income Tax Act, Value Added Tax (VAT) Act, and other tax/regulatory legislation, consolidating them into a single framework administered by the Nigeria Revenue Service (NRS). For operators and contractors under existing PSCs, this is not just a cosmetic change because the fiscal terms that governed cost recovery and profit-sharing calculations were anchored on the repealed Act.
The consolidation raises interpretive questions about which provisions remain unchanged, which ones are modified by the NTA’s general deduction and administration rules, and which ones now depend on stabilization clauses in individual contracts to preserve pre-existing terms. The NTA operates alongside, not in place of, the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) 2021, which remains the primary framework for upstream fiscal and regulatory matters, including cost recovery/approval mechanics for PSCs, joint ventures, and other contract types. Where the two frameworks intersect, particularly on what constitutes an allowable or recoverable cost, is likely where most of the near-term dispute risks sit.
NUPRC’s Cost Efficiency Incentives Order: A New Layer of Scrutiny
In April 2025, the Federal Government issued the Upstream Petroleum Operations (Cost Efficiency Incentives) Order (CEI), made under Section 8 of the PIA, which empowers NUPRC to set cost benchmarks for evaluating upstream operations. The Order does not itself rewrite cost recovery rules, rather, it makes an operator’s actual operating cost, measured against an annually published benchmark, directly relevant to a tax outcome.
Under the framework, NUPRC conducts annual benchmarking studies to set Unit Operating Cost targets by terrain (onshore, shallow water, and deep offshore), and operators whose actual costs come in below the benchmark become eligible for a tax credit calculated as a share of the government’s incremental take from that saving. NUPRC then forwards a list of qualifying companies to the tax authority to validate claims.
Why this creates dispute exposure
1. The benchmarking methodology is set by NUPRC in consultation with industry, but the annual target-setting and classification of what counts toward Actual Operating Cost versus Target Operating Cost is inherently contestable. The same cost items that generate dispute in normal cost-recovery audits (allocated overhead, decommissioning provisions, intercompany service charges) now also determine eligibility for a tax credit.
2. The credit computation caps a lessee’s take at 50% of after-tax savings and limits annual utilisation to 20% of actual tax liability, with unutilised amounts carried forward for only three years, with the CEI sunsetting on 31 May 2035, unless renewed. This creates timing disputes where an operator’s cost position and the tax authority’s assessment diverge in a way that affects not just the current year but a multi-year carryforward position.
3. As qualification runs through the NUPRC before the NRS validates the claim, an operator now faces two regulators with potentially different reads on the same cost data, which may appear as a structural setup for the kind of cross-agency dispute that is already visible elsewhere in the sector.