January 31, 2023
Prior to January 2020 when the first Finance Act was signed into law, the Nigerian tax laws had not been reviewed for several years and tax positions adopted by non-resident companies (NRC) on their Nigerian tax matters tended to subsist for a long time. This has since changed as the Federal Government has used annual Finance Acts as a fiscal tool to amend relevant laws that impact how businesses are carried on in Nigeria.
The introduction of the Finance Act to improve the ease of doing business and align the tax laws to global best practices has been largely positive. To date, about 167 amendments have been introduced and the full impact of these amendments will only be seen in the next couple of years as the business environments improves with the imminent change in Government by May 2023.
As the country awaits the President’s assent on the latest Finance Act 2022, this article seeks to evaluate some of the amendments to the tax laws introduced by the Finance Act that impact NRCs operations in Nigeria.
Companies Income Tax – The Quest to Include More NRCs in the Tax Net
On 24 July 2014, the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) mandated NRCs to file full tax returns like their Nigerian counterparts. This was a departure from the norm as NRCs were previously subject to tax on deemed tax basis. In effect, the NRCs were required to include actual profits made from Nigerian operations, capital allowance computations and audited financial statements effective from 1 January 2015 based on a Public Notice issued by the FIRS. The intention of the FIRS was to have more visibility on the actual financial results of NRC’s operations in Nigeria with the hope of collecting more tax revenue.
The above approach did not yield much results as many NRCs reported losses. Some NRCs were also not liable to tax based on the extant laws at the time. Consequently, the basis of taxing NRCs as provided in Section 13 of the Companies Income Tax (CIT) Act was reviewed and amended by the Finance Acts. Currently, NRCs are subjected to tax where;
iii. the trade or business or activities of the non-resident involves a single contract for surveys, deliveries, installations or construction;
The amendments introduced in paragraph (iii) to (v) above brought more NRCs into the tax net even where they did not have a fixed base or permanent establishment in Nigeria. Many NRCS earn more than ₦25m (requirement to qualify for SEP) from remote operations in Nigeria which may not have been the case prior to the amendment. Thus, NRCs operating in Nigeria should review their operations and ascertain that they do not have new tax obligations in Nigeria based on the above.
Are Double Tax Treaties Sufficient to Shield NRCs from Tax?
Nigeria has Double Tax Treaties (DTT) with 16 countries which is aimed at ensuring a company resident in the DTT state suffers tax only once for income derived from any of the contracting jurisdictions. Typically, the DTTs provide that an NRC will only be liable to CIT in Nigeria where it has a Permanent Establishment (PE) in Nigeria. A PE is essentially a Fixed Place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on.
Consequently, where there is no PE, there is no CIT applicable to the NRC. Given most DTT between Nigeria and other countries have not been updated to cover remote digital, technical, professional, management or consulting services, an NRC located in a DTT country will not be liable to tax in Nigeria if it does not have a PE in Nigeria (or other conditions for taxation under the DTT) even where the income earned from Nigeria exceeds the SEP threshold. Section 45 of the CITA is very clear that arrangements between Nigeria and other countries under a DTT supersedes the provisions of the CIT Act.
The above notwithstanding, the FIRS issued a circular dated 3 June 2021 on the claim of DTT benefits in Nigeria. Based on the circular, the claim of DTT benefit is no longer automatic as intending companies are required to submit a formal application to the relevant tax authority, complete a certificate of residence and a claim for the applicable tax credit.
In addition, the reduced tax rate of 7.5% applicable on dividends, interests and royalties earned by taxable persons resident in a DTT state has been terminated by the FIRS with effect from 1 July 2022. Consequently, the applicable withholding tax (WHT) rate provided in the enabling laws will apply except where such rate exceeds the maximum rate provided in the applicable DTA. Hence, NRCs receiving passive income based on their investment in Nigerian companies will pay more taxes based on the amendments introduced by the Finance Acts.
Capital Gains Tax and Withdrawal of Incentive Associated with Investment in Nigerian Companies
Prior to the Finance Acts, where a Nigerian company has 25% imported equity, such a company is exempted from minimum tax. Based on the amendment introduced by Finance Act 2019, this incentive has been removed. The introduction was intended to create a level playing ground for Nigerian companies without imported capital. However, this may impact the attractiveness of investing in Nigerian companies given that the minimum tax is 2.5% of turnover and investors may have to take loans to pay the minimum tax due to the government where the company is making losses.