October 18, 2022
According to the 2020 Guidelines for the Award and Operations of Marginal Fields in Nigeria published by the defunct Department of Petroleum Resources (DPR), a marginal field is any field that has been discovered and has been left unattended for a period of not less than ten (10) years, from the date of first discovery or such field as the President may, from time to time, identify as a marginal field. Subsequent to the designation of oil fields as marginal fields, there is usually a bidding process through which the marginal fields would be “farmed-out” to third parties under farm out agreements (FOAs) with the original lease holders.
The government’s main objectives for promoting this arrangement were to promote indigenous participation in Nigeria’s oil and gas industry, increase the oil and gas reserves base and provide employment opportunities for the teeming population.
However, one of the major characteristics of marginal fields is that these fields may not have been considered for development by the lease holder because of assumed uneconomic returns under prevailing fiscal and market terms. In essence, the economics of a marginal field may not be considered as commercially viable using conventional development methods under the prevailing fiscal regime.
Hence, the government incentivized investments in such projects. For instance, marginal fields had lower royalty rates and some of the indigenous operators were able to enjoy tax holidays through the Pioneer Status Incentive scheme.
However, the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), 2021 which was signed into law on 16 August 2021 introduced a new fiscal and regulatory framework for marginal field operations. In this article, we have reviewed the PIA to identify the “good” and the “improvable” provisions impacting marginal fields. The “good” provisions are those that will positively impact the marginal fields, while the “improvable” provisions are provisions that seem to be unfair or ambiguous and could adversely impact marginal fields.
The “Good” Provisions
The PIA reduces the headline tax rates of marginal field operators from 85% to 45%. Specifically, marginal fields will now be liable to Hydrocarbon Tax (HCT) and Companies Income Tax at 15% and 30% respectively. This steep reduction in the headline tax rate could be seen as an incentive to be enjoyed by the operators. However, it should be noted that the effective tax rate (ETR) may exceed 45% as the PIA provides for the non-deductibility of certain expenses such as finance costs and bank charges, for the purpose of computing HCT. More so, the cost-price ratio ceiling of 65% of revenue for deductible costs may also increase the ETR of the affected companies.
Prior to the enactment of the PIA, the original lease holders maintained overriding rights over the petroleum operations to be carried out by the farmee. For instance, depending on the terms of the FOA, the farmor could be entitled to earn overriding royalties from production in the field. The terms for deep drilling were also embedded in the FOA, which implied that the farmor could lay claim to petroleum discoveries below the depth agreed in the FOA. Also, there was no clarity on whether marginal fields could continue to operate after the expiration of the license of the farmor.
However, under the PIA, marginal field operators will now be awarded Petroleum Mining Leases (PMLs) and Petroleum Prospecting Licenses (PPLs). Going forward, it is expected that the marginal field operators would have the exclusive right to conduct petroleum operations within the field. They will also have a direct relationship with the government instead of the initial lease holders.
Furthermore, the PIA provides that no new marginal field will be declared under the PIA, thereby confirming the government’s intention of phasing out the current marginal field arrangements.
However, it should be noted that the PIA does not provide a clear framework for transition of existing marginal fields to the PIA regime and this appears to be an “improvable” provision as further explained below.