March 22, 2022
Over the last few years, Nigeria has made concerted efforts at improving its World Bank Ease of Doing Business Ranking and in the Doing Business Report, of 2020, Nigeria ranked 131st out of 190 economies.2 This was an improvement from its ranking of 145th out of 190 in 2019.3 The improvement in the ranking was driven by impressive performance in the following focal areas – Starting a Business, Dealing with Construction Permits, Getting Electricity, Registering Property, Trading Across Borders and Enforcing Contracts. Unfortunately, Nigeria continued to underperform in areas like – Paying Taxes, Getting Credit, Protecting Minority Investors and Resolving Insolvency. The report therefore indicates that Nigeria needs to do more in terms of improving efficiency and ease of compliance with its tax system.
One factor which has continually impacted negatively on the efficiency of the Nigerian tax system is the issue of multiplicity and duplication of taxes. This article will therefore discuss the multiplicity of taxes in the light of the current tax and economic landscape, the effects of multiplicity of taxes on the Nigerian economy and solutions that can be adopted by policymakers and legislators to resolve this issue.
Meaning of Multiplicity of Taxes
According to the National Tax Policy 2012, multiple taxation means or includes ‘‘the imposition of the same or similar taxes on the same income base, transaction or person by one or more levels of Government, in one or more jurisdiction’’4. The updated National Tax Policy 2017 describes multiple taxation as a situation, where taxes similar to those being collected by a level of government are introduced by the same or another level of government.5
The Current Tax and Economic Landscape
Globally, countries are experiencing rising costs of commodities, inflation, supply chain disruptions, excess demand and reduced supply, protectionism and increased economic nationalism. The rippling effects of these realities are tangible across the Nigerian economy with more businesses struggling to survive and the government grappling with revenue shortfall. The easy option seems to be for governments to make recourse to taxation as an alternative for improving revenue and balancing its budget, however this raises the risk of increased multiple taxation.
At the Federal Level of Government, there have been numerous Bills at the National Assembly, which seek to introduce new taxes on existing taxpayers and tax bases. For example, in 2021, a Tertiary Hospital Development Fund Bill, 2021 was considered at the Senate. This Bill seeks to establish a Tertiary Hospital Development Fund, which will be partly financed by the introduction of a Tertiary Hospital Development Tax, which will comprise – 1% of petroleum companies tax paid on total barrels of crude oil produced yearly,6 1% of mobile phone service providers tax paid on airtime and data sold yearly,7 1% of beverages and breweries companies tax paid on profit yearly declared,8 1% of cement companies on profit yearly declared,9 1% of paint and chemical manufacturing companies tax paid on profit yearly declared10 and 1% of tobacco companies tax paid on profit declared.11 The Bill empowers the FIRS to assess and collect these taxes and remit same to the Fund.12 Additionally in the Finance Act, 2021, excise was imposed on non-alcoholic beverages, along with an increase in the rate of the Tertiary Education Tax.
At the State and Local Government levels, new taxes are being introduced, in addition to numerous compulsory and sometimes, unlawful taxes and levies, that are imposed and collected by Local Governments across Nigeria. There are possibly numerous Bills like the Tertiary Hospital Development Fund Bill, which are currently before the National Assembly, that seek to introduce some form of earmarked taxes or general taxes on already overburdened taxpayers. The negative impact of these additional taxes are myriad, for example, there is an usually high business mortality rate in Nigeria, high attrition of foreign investors from the Nigerian market, reduced competitiveness of the Nigerian market as a destination for new foreign investment and increased capital flight arising from divestment from Nigeria and reinvestment in other markets. These realities may be increased and accelerated when the African Continental Free Trade Area Agreement becomes fully operational, with Nigeria losing and its neighbors benefiting.