June 28, 2022
It is not uncommon for countries to reach bilateral or multilateral agreements to protect their citizens from multiple taxation on the same income, ease international relations and encourage global mobility. One of such agreements is the double tax treaty (DTT) which basically protects companies / individuals against double taxation of the same income and allows taxpayers that have suffered tax on an income in one country to claim foreign tax credit to offset tax liabilities in another country based on the relevant agreement.
Recently, the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) issued a Circular (“the Circular”) titled “Information Circular on the Claim of Tax Treaties Benefits and Commonwealth Tax Relief in Nigeria”. The Circular was issued further to the FIRS’ public notice communicating the Honourable Minister of Finance, Budget and National Planning (“the Minister”)’s approval of the discontinuation of the unilateral application of a uniform Withholding Tax (WHT) rate of 7.5% on dividends, interest and royalties paid by residents of Nigeria and beneficially owned by residents of its treaty partners under the DTTs between Nigeria and other countries.
On the other hand, certain taxpayers in Nigeria have recently encountered setbacks in taking advantage of the foreign tax credits specifically stated in the law. The FIRS’ view is that “there must be a corresponding relief of the same manner in the other jurisdiction, in such a way that provides reciprocity between the two countries”.
In this article, we examine the concept of reciprocity in tax administration, discuss the critical issues to consider for developing policies hinged on reciprocation, and analyse recent reversals of reciprocal provisions including potential implications for investments.
The Concept of Reciprocity in Tax Administration
The 9th Edition of the Black’s Law Dictionary defines reciprocity as “the mutual concession of advantages or privileges for purposes of commercial or diplomatic relations”. Going by this definition, the concept of reciprocity in tax administration can be said to be the mutual arrangement between two states to concede advantages and privileges with relation to taxes for the purpose of commercial or diplomatic relations.
In simple terms, Country A and Country B can reach a mutual agreement on how the income earned by individuals / companies who are citizens / residents of either of the countries and work or earn income in the other country should be taxed. Depending on the agreement, the countries can choose to only assess the income to tax in the country where the income was earned (source country) or reduce the percentage of tax to be paid in the source country.
From a critical point of view, Nigeria still has a long way to go in terms of its ease of doing business when compared with other countries. Thus, it is important to compare several economic factors such as security index and infrastructural development amongst others before demanding reciprocity from those countries that are typically better ranked for ease of doing business. It is also important to give thought to the quantum of Nigerian capital available in other jurisdictions vis-à-vis foreign capital needed to achieve growth in Nigeria.
Analysis of examples of reversals on reciprocal provisions and potential implications for investments
Prior to the release of the above-referenced Circular, Nigeria had communicated a WHT rate of 7.5% on dividends, interest and royalties paid by residents of Nigeria and beneficially owned by residents of its treaty partners under the DTTs between Nigeria and other countries. However, with the Minister’s approval, the rates specified in the tax laws shall apply, except where it exceeds the maximum rate specified in the tax treaty, effective 1 July 2022 as against the previous 7.5% which has been in application in the last 23 years.
On the other hand, Section 44 (1) of the Companies Income Tax (CIT) Act grants Commonwealth Income Tax Relief (CTR) to Nigerian companies that have suffered taxes on income or profits based on a law in force in any country within the Commonwealth or in the Republic of Ireland, provided that the country also provides for same relief in a manner corresponding to the relief granted by the CIT Act.