October 26, 2022
On 21 July 2022, the Tax Appeal Tribunal (TAT or “the Tribunal”) sitting in Lagos, issued a Ruling in the case of Dangote Industries Limited (“Dangote” or “the Company”) vs Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS or “the Service”) on issues relating to fair hearing, Excess Dividend Tax and Value Added Tax (VAT) on reimbursable expenses. The TAT mostly found that Dangote was given ample time to argue its case and adduce evidence to substantiate its claims of non-taxability and the Company failed to provide such documentary evidence.
In addition, while the TAT held that the FIRS could not charge VAT on the Company’s reimbursable expenses, the Tribunal was unable to uphold the non-taxability of alleged pioneer profits and franked investment income of Dangote due to the unavailability of evidence to support the Company’s claims.
Following an audit conducted on Dangote in 2017 for the years 2013 to 2015, the FIRS wrote to the Company on 2 March 2018 indicating its intention to raise an assessment on the Company. In the said letter, the FIRS highlighted that it had adjusted the Company’s assessable profits to include some expenses which it claimed were not wholly, reasonably, exclusively and necessarily incurred for the running of the business. The FIRS also charged the dividends paid out by the Company to tax at 30% on the basis that in the year of distribution, tax was not payable on the Company’s total profits as provided under Section 19 of the Companies Income Tax (CIT) Act. Furthermore, the FIRS claimed that the Company did not fully remit Withholding Tax (WHT), VAT and Stamp Duties on some qualifying transactions.
Based on the above adjustments, the FIRS issued a Notice of Additional Assessment to the Company on 20 March 2018. The Company objected to the Notice of Additional Assessment on 23 March 2018 and reconciliation meetings commenced from 24 May 2018 until 18 February 2019 when the FIRS issued its final Notice of Refusal to Amend (NORA). Despite the NORA issued, there were still unsuccessful attempts to resolve the issues between parties between May and June 2019. As a result, the FIRS issued a final Assessment Notice on 26 November 2019. Consequently, Dangote filed an appeal at the TAT challenging the FIRS’s position.
At the TAT, the crux of the issues between the parties were as follows:
In resolving the issues raised, the Tribunal decided partly in favour of the FIRS and partly in favour of Dangote.
On the issue of fair hearing, the Tribunal resolved this issue in favour of the FIRS stating that Dangote was actually given ample opportunity to counter the assessments issued by the FIRS and failed to do so and should not complain about fair hearing.
On the issue of the legality of the additional assessments to CIT, WHT and VAT, the TAT decided that the FIRS did not act illegally in the issuance of the additional assessment because critical and relevant documents required to substantiate the claims of the Company for a reduced tax liability were not made available for the review of the FIRS.
On the issue of the application of VAT on reimbursable expenses, the Tribunal ruled in favour of Dangote stating that the FIRS failed to consider the effect of the gross up arrangement between the parties when it applied VAT of 7.5% on the gross up amount. Thus, the TAT stated that the FIRS should make necessary adjustments and issue a reduced VAT assessment. More so, the FIRS did not contest the contention of Dangote on this issue.
On the issue of the application of Section 19 on Excess Dividend on pioneer profits and franked investment income of the Company, the TAT agreed that although Section 19 is an anti-avoidance provision that states that tax should be applicable on the dividends distributed by a company provided that the dividends are distributed in excess of the total taxable profits of a company, such tax should not be applied to dividends distributed from pioneer profits (which is already exempt from tax under the Industrial Development (Income Tax Relief) Act) and franked investment income (which is exempt from tax under Section 80(3) of the CIT Act). However, despite the position of the Tribunal, it was unable to rule in favour of Dangote due to an absence of documentary evidence to support the claim of the Company that its dividends for the affected years were distributed from pioneer profits and franked investment income. The TAT, however, directed the Company to make available all documents requested by the FIRS within a period of two weeks from the date of its Ruling to enable the FIRS review and make all adjustments necessary to the assessment in contention; failing which the assessment in contention will stand confirmed to be final and conclusive and liable to be paid accordingly.
This decision buttresses the importance of provision of documentary evidence to support taxpayers’ claims during tax audit as failure to provide required evidence may result in unforeseen tax liabilities.
On the non-applicability of Excess Dividend Tax on the Company’s pioneer profits and franked investment income, the decision of the Tribunal in this case is a clear departure from previous judicial decisions on similar issues. In the 2019 case of United Capital Assets Management Limited (UCAM) v Federal Inland Revenue Service, the TAT upheld the application of Excess Dividend Tax on income which was exempt from CIT. Similarly, the Federal High Court and the Court of Appeal have previously held in the cases of Oando v FIRS (2016) and Oando v FBIR (2015) that whenever a company distributes dividends in excess of its profits in any year, the excess dividends distributed would be subject to CIT even if paid from already taxed earnings.
Thankfully, the Finance Act 2019 clearly introduced categories of profits that will not be subjected to Excess Dividend Tax under Section 19 as follows:
Thus, in line with the decision of the Tribunal, we expect to see less controversies with respect to the application of Section 19 of the CIT Act. Notwithstanding this, it is the responsibility of taxpayers to ensure that they provide sufficient documentary evidence to support their claim of non-taxability under Section 19 where the need arises.