December 9, 2025
Nigeria’s sweeping 2025 tax reform, coupled with an increasing focus on effective and smart revenue collection and administration, is fundamentally redefining the tax risk landscape for taxpayers and their advisers. The enactment of the suite of 2025 Tax Reform Acts, principally the Nigeria Tax Act, 2025 (NTA), together with the Nigeria Tax Administration Act, 2025 (NTAA) and companion laws, consolidates and modernises federal tax laws, some aspects of State tax laws, expands administrative powers, strengthens penalties, and introduces measures (e.g., controlled foreign company (CFC) rules, etc.) that are inherently litigation-prone as taxpayers seek judicial clarity on the limits of new statutory provisions.
Simultaneously, courts and tribunals in recent times have produced a body of case law that both corrects and occasionally validates the Federal Inland Revenue Service’s (and state revenue authorities’) assessment and collection practices. Lawyers and consultants must align compliance programs, audit preparations, defences and litigation strategies to a new, high-intensity enforcement environment.
On 26th June 2025, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu signed into law the package commonly referred to as the 2025 Tax Reform Acts. The reforms consolidate fragmented statutes into a unified statutory architecture; the Nigeria Tax Act (NTA), 2025, the Nigeria Tax Administration Act (NTAA), 2025, the Nigeria Revenue Service (Establishment) Act (NRSA), 2025, and the Joint Revenue Board (Establishment) Act, 2025. The reforms also strengthen administrative tools for registration, information-gathering, assessment and enforcement, and add substantive measures such as CFC rules and a top-up tax to meet international minimum tax obligations – Sections 6 (2), (3) and 57 of the NTA. This new architecture, particularly the expanded administrative powers and tighter penalty regimes in the NTAA, establishes the legal basis for the high-intensity enforcement environment which will going forward, define tax dispute resolution and tax litigation in Nigeria.
The consolidation of tax laws, as we now have it, clarifies many grey areas but still creates fresh interpretive questions, such as new definitions, transitional rules and administrative powers. This generates a risk of litigation as taxpayers and revenue authorities dispute over boundaries (e.g., scope of taxable base, retroactivity, transitional treatment, etc.). Against this backdrop, the litigation environment is producing judicial precedent on how aggressively the new laws can be enforced.
a. Frequent “Best of Judgment”, Estimate-Based Assessments, and Judicial Pushback Currently, an observable trend is the judiciary’s increased willingness to ensure that the FIRS works within the statutory limits of its power to use administrative assessment methods (including Best-of-Judgment (BoJ) assessments), to determine the liability of taxpayers. This judicial intervention is crucial and will become even more critical in the nearest future, in an era where the FIRS will be expected to use expanded administrative powers under the new Act to issue additional assessments on taxpayers, especially in situations where it is unable to access the taxpayer’s records and books.
A notable example is the 2024 Court of Appeal decision in Federal Inland Revenue Service v. Agromix Nigeria Ltd [2024] 87 TLRN 1, where the Court examined limits on using capital assets values as the basis for BoJ assessments. In that case, the FIRS had attempted to determine the company’s taxable income base on the value of its capital assets (plant, property and equipment). The Court decisively rejected that approach and held that BoJ assessments must be based on taxable profits and within statutory authority. That decision is an important reminder that tax authorities must work within the confines of the strict interpretation of the law when raising new assessments or additional assessments. See also FBIR V. Halliburton (WA) Ltd [2016] 4 NWLR (Pt. 1501) 53, P. 89, Paras. F-G.
The above case underscores the necessity of a proactive approach by taxpayers who are subject to BoJ assessment by ensuring that the methodology used in raising such assessments is based strictly on the parameters prescribed by the tax laws, as seen in the Agromix case. A successful defence strategy would hinge on demonstrating the arbitrary or non-compliant nature of the method a tax authority used in computing the tax.