November 16, 2021
There was excitement in the international tax space on 8 October 2021, with the announcement of a Two-Pillar solution to address the tax challenges associated with globalization and the digital economy.
The landmark deal will ensure that affected Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) are assessed to tax at a global minimum rate of 15% from 2023 and will reallocate profits from the world’s largest and most profitable MNEs to countries worldwide, ensuring that these companies pay a fair share of tax wherever they operate and generate revenues.
This decision by the OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework (IF) on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting marks a major reform of the international tax system, with 137 IF members (as at 4 November 2021) being signatory members with the exclusion of Nigeria.
In this article, we have summarized the Two-Pillar solution and evaluated the implications from a Nigerian perspective.
The Two-Pillar Solution: Summary
Pillar 1: Profit Re-Allocation
Pillar 1 provides an approach that accommodates increasing changes in business models arising from digitization by introducing new nexus rules and profit allocation mechanisms which as a result, expands the taxing rights of market jurisdictions where income is generated by the MNEs.
Pillar 1 applies to In-scope MNEs which are MNEs with global turnover above €20 billion and a profit-margin above 10%. An In-scope MNE will be deemed to be taxable in any member jurisdiction where it derives at least €1 million revenue in any financial year. For developing economies, such as Nigeria, where the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is lower than €40 billion, a reduced revenue threshold of €250,000 applies.
Pillar 1 seeks to re-allocate twenty-five percent (25%) of In-scope MNEs residual profit to other member jurisdictions where the MNEs derived the global revenue from using a revenue-based allocation mechanism and the simplified-streamlined arm’s length remuneration for marketing and distribution activities.
Pillar 2: Global Minimum Tax
Pillar 2 establishes a framework for a global minimum taxation regime through a series of interlocking rules. These include Global Anti-Base Erosion (GloBE)5 rules (Income Inclusion Rule – IIR and Undertaxed Payment Rule- UTPR) and the treaty-based Subject to Tax Rule (STTR).
The IIR imposes top-up tax on the income of a foreign entity, at the jurisdiction of the Parent Entity, if that income was ab-initio subject to an effective tax rate that is below 15%. While the UTPR6 denies deductions or requires an equivalent adjustment to the extent that the low tax income of a constituent entity is not subject to tax under an IIR.
The STTR allows source jurisdictions to impose withholding tax at a minimum rate of 9% on certain related party payments (interest and royalties).
The GloBE rules applies to large MNEs with over €750 million7 annual consolidated revenue. The goal is to ensure that large MNEs are globally taxed at a minimum of 15%, and reduce the appetite for aggressive use of tax havens.
The Two-Pillar solution has been estimated to impose taxing rights on more than $125 billion of profit for re-allocation and generate around $150 billion new tax revenue globally per year, as well as the additional benefits of stabilization of the international tax system and increase in tax certainty for both taxpayers and administrators.
The Two-Pillar solution also mandates signatory IF members to suspend existing Digital Sales Tax (DST) and prohibits an introduction of any variant of DST after the commencement of the Two-Pillar initiative in 2023.
Lastly, the OECD is committed to assist with the drafting of multilateral instruments and also provide support to tax administrations for seamless implementation of the Two-Pillar solution.