November 23, 2021
One of the important operating decisions a company makes is the establishment of a model for setting the prices of its products and services. The ability of a company to meet its daily financial obligations and profitability largely depends on the pricing model. Given that companies (asides non-profit organizations) operate to maximize profits in the long run, the cost-plus pricing model is usually adopted by companies in certain industries as it guarantees recovery of cost and profitability.
The idea behind cost-plus model involves adding a mark-up percentage to the cost of a product or service, in the determination of its selling price. The mark-up percentage could either be stipulated by the customer (as it is usually the case in a contract agreement) or by the company (as it is the case with representative offices and retail companies). Despite the apparent seamlessness of this model, when a company’s products or service offerings are priced on the basis of cost-plus, there is an implicit assumption that the total amount received (cost plus mark-up) represents the company’s revenue.
In order to improve comparability across industries and companies using different business models, the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) issued a new accounting standard: International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 15 which establishes the principles for revenue recognition. Although, IFRS 15 does not specifically address cost-plus arrangement, it requires a company to assess whether it is a principal or an agent for each specified service promised to the customer. The ascertainment of a company’s role as a principal or as an agent requires judgement in some circumstances, and different conclusions can significantly affect the amount and timing of revenue recognized.
This article seeks to consider the definition of gross turnover as stipulated by the Finance Acts, 2019 & 2020, the diverse interpretations by taxpayers and the tax authority and the corresponding tax implications for companies operating a cost-plus model.
Prior to the enactment of the Finance Act (FA) 2019, there was no explicit definition of “gross turnover” in the provisions of the tax laws. In 2020 however, the Companies Income Tax Act (CITA) was amended by the FA 2019, and it defined gross turnover as “the gross inflow of economic benefits (cash, revenues, receivables, other assets) arising from the operating activities of a company, including sales of goods, supply of services, receipt of interest, rents, royalties or dividends”.
The FA 2020 further amended the CITA and now defines gross turnover to mean “the gross inflow of economic benefit during the period arising in the course of the operating activities of an entity when those inflow results in increase in equity, other than increases relating to contributions from equity participant, including sale of goods, supply of service, receipt of interest, rent, royalties or dividends”.
Based on the above definitions, the meaning of gross turnover introduced by the FAs was aimed at addressing seeming ambiguities that have until then, subsisted in the provisions of the tax laws. The definition of turnover for tax purposes is important in determining the minimum tax payable by companies and the threshold for exemption from companies income tax, amongst other tax considerations.
There are a number of entities adopting the cost-plus model in Nigeria based on the structure of their business operations. This is particularly a common model adopted by representative offices of non-resident companies where the representative provides business support in form of logistics and management of operations in Nigeria. The mark-up on the reimbursed cost may be determined by the company’s targeted internal rate of return on investment as agreed by the parties, subject to Transfer Pricing considerations.
Given the above, it is possible to assume that only the mark-up portion constitutes “payment” received for the services rendered and represents the economic benefit to the company. However, the reimbursed cost does not constitute “income” in the hands of the company, since it is cost incurred on behalf of another party. Other proponents are of the view that the entire amount received i.e. the mark-up and the reimbursed costs, constitute “payment” received for the services rendered, which in turn is the economic benefit to the companies operating this model.