August 20, 2024
On 17 July 2024, Nigerians woke up to the news of a letter alongside an executive bill sent by President Bola Ahmed Tinubu (“the President”) to the Nigerian Senate, requesting an amendment to the Finance Act, 2023 via the Finance Bill 2024 (“the Bill”). The Bill sets to impose a one-time tax called windfall tax (“the tax) of 50% on the realised foreign exchange profits derived by banks in the 2023 Financial Year (FY). The tax as proposed by the President, would help fund capital infrastructure development, access to education and healthcare, and other public welfare initiatives.
The proposed windfall tax is a response to the significant profits made by banks from foreign exchange transactions mainly from excessive currency devaluation or fluctuation. The exchange volatility has been largely driven by key forces including foreign exchange rate unification, fluctuating oil prices, incessant hikes in interest rates due to persistent inflation, etc. The impact of this is that many businesses including multinationals, are winding up their businesses and running into significant losses that wiped off even their shareholders’ funds. However, amidst these economic woes, Nigerian banks have generated huge extraordinary profits with a total estimate of about ₦4.4 trillion in the full year 2023 and another ₦2.03 trillion alone in the first quarter of 2024. The projection has also shown that the annual total profits before tax of banks could exceed ₦8.2 trillion in 2024 FY alone. It is important to mention that, a substantial portion of these profits arise from foreign exchange gains often made from increase in the value of foreign currency reserves relative to the Naira.
Accordingly, this article seeks to examine the proposed windfall tax on foreign exchange gains of banks in Nigeria and its globally-perceived impacts on the economy.
Windfall taxes are one-off special taxes imposed by governments on companies that have unexpectedly or unreasonably high profits, typically due to favourable market conditions rather than the company’s efforts. These profits are often seen as “unearned” or “extraordinary” and are taxed at higher rates to redistribute wealth or fund public services. Windfall taxes are commonly applied in various industries where unusually favourable market conditions or government policy leads to substantial or unexpected profits. The taxes are employed by governments to address economic imbalances, fund social programs, and redistribute societal wealth among the populace.
In Nigeria, the proposed windfall tax seeks to tax the excess profits of banks, specifically those relating to realised foreign exchange transactions arising from government policies on Naira which inadvertently favoured banks as compared to companies operating in other industries such as manufacturing entities. The proposed Bill upon review and approval by the Senate increased the rate of the windfall tax to 70% on the realised foreign exchange profits derived by banks from the period covering June 2023 when the policy on unification of exchange rate commenced, up to 31st December 2025. Notwithstanding, the review and increase in rate is still subject to the President’s assent. The tax is to be assessed, collected, and administered by the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS). The Bill also grants the taxpayer an option to remit the taxes in instalments provided that it executes a deferred payment agreement with FIRS on or before 31 December 2024.
Furthermore, Nigerian banks that fail to remit the required taxes to FIRS and fail to agree on an instalment plan within the stipulated timeline would be liable to pay the tax, plus a penalty of 10% of the tax not paid per annum, plus interest at the prevailing Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) minimum discount rate. Upon prosecution, the principal officers of such defaulting bank may also be imprisoned for a period not more than 3 years.
Since 29 May 2023, the Presidency in the bid to reshape the economy and attract foreign investors, has introduced several reforms and policies ranging from the removal of fuel and electricity subsidies, unification of the exchange rate, increase in CBN interest rate by at least 800 basis points to control persistent inflation among others. However, these reforms seem to have exacerbated the economic challenges faced by individuals and businesses, rather than ameliorating them. The huge devaluation of the Naira, persistent increase in the cost of living, high inflation rate, and interest rate, have negatively impacted liquidity, undermining investors’ confidence to invest in the economy and repatriate their investments at any preferred time.
The above, coupled with the challenges of financing the huge budget deficit of about 32%, as well as declining oil revenue have led to the government seeking ingenious means of financing government expenditure. The proposed Windfall tax allows the government the opportunity to generate additional revenue without directly increasing the tax burden on other sectors of the economy. This initiative could yield revenue as much as 0.3% of the 2024 GDP as reported by Nairametrics.